Pneumatic system-
v
System operated with Air.
v
Open loop system
v
Generally used for low pressure
v
Generally delivers less force compared to hydraulic
system
v
Cheaper compared to hydraulic for basic cost. But
compressor running cost is more
Hydraulic system-
v
System operated with fluid - oil.
v
Closed loop system
v
High pressure system
v
Generally used for heavy force delivery
v
Initial cost is high
v
More expensive
Pneumatic system is mostly preferred over hydraulic system in BIW welding fixture.
All toggle clamp, pin cylinder, slides are operated via pneumatic.
Generally cylinder are designed to operate max pressure 12-13 bar. As it expensive and difficult to maintain 10-12 bar in shop floor it is preferred to do design pneumatic systems at 6 bar pressure